12 Best Cabin Rentals Near Shelter Island, NY, US 2025

United States
—
New York
—
Shelter Island

97% (136 reviews)

Popular camping styles for Shelter Island

Public campgrounds near Shelter Island

91%

(17)

3 top cabins sites near Shelter Island

96%

(172)

Humble Farm with Simplicity

10 sites · Lodging, RVs, Tents3 acres · Higganum, CT

Bring your family & friends to camp at our quiet and very modest small farm. Located in backwoods horse pastures with chickens, a dog, and a couple of horses. The property is very spread out and there are 2 outhouses for all sites to use. Your pets are welcome too! Locally there are state parks with beaches, and state forest for trails and lakes, hiking and biking. Or you can just relax and enjoy the serenity! OUR ADDRESS IS #200 NOT #204 THE DRIVEWAY TO THE LEFT FROM THE STREET IS OURS., THE ONE PARALLEL TO THE RIGHT FROM THE STREET IS OUR NEIGHBOURS. Other attractions include local farmers markets, Gilette's Castle, and the famous River Ferry crossing the Connecticut River with a vehicle across to East Haddam. We offer an hot H2O outdoor shower here for the comfort of out clients. It is located on the back of main house in corner. See map in photos. We cannot allow any wood for camp fires to be brought in form the outside for environmental reasons. It can be pre-purchased for $12 per bundle on this site, or $10.00 cash here at farm. Farm Fresh eggs daily when available for $5.00 per 1/2 dozen. There are blankets and pillows are provided, and linens for cabin or trailer sites. Garbage removal is available as well $5 per bag provided.

Booked 1 time

Two Herons Farm

2 sites · Lodging12 acres · Portland, CT

Come stay on our working farm! Relax and enjoy all that our farm has to offer. You can enjoy nature and privacy or opt for a more interactive experience and join our morning or evening farm tour where you can interact with goats, sheep, mini-horses, pigs, chickens, ducks, and more. We are a small family farm where we raise animals and grow flowers/food. Our family home was built in 1739 and is situated near the street entrance. As you enter the property, you will see two cottages, the oldest corn crib in the county, and a beautifully restored 1800s barn. There is a vintage-style camper to the left of the barn, located in an area where you can have privacy overlooking the pastures. We live on the property and can assist guests with anything that they might need. Guests are welcome to stroll around the property and enjoy all it has to offer. We have a farm store and education center opening summer of 2025! Check our website to see classes and offerings that you might take advantage of during your stay. Please note, that we ask that guests do not enter the barn or fenced pasture without one of the farm owners (Molly & Diego). Our animals are accustomed to people, but livestock is unpredictable, especially to people that they do not know. There is plenty of area outside of the pasture that guests can enjoy. If you opt for a farm tour we promise that you will have plenty of interaction with our many animals.

Eagle View Cabin

1 site · Lodging4 acres · East Lyme, CT

We are across from a private lake with eagles.The property is 2 miles from rocky neck state park and beach.There are many walking trails within rocky neck.This is a beautiful state park that is not commercial.The Beach has fine white sand and the water is on a sand bar that has no rocks.Niantic is a quaint town with 3 more beaches.

Nearby parks

Explore the area’s public lands.

91%

(17)

Burlingame State Park

Quonochontaug, Rhode Island

81%

(8)

Hammonasset Beach State Park

Jewett City, Connecticut

Last Green Valley National Heritage Corridor

100%

(1)

Last Green Valley National Heritage Corridor

Danielson, Connecticut

Happy farmer sitting in a truck in a grassy field

Cabins near Shelter Island guide

Overview

Looking to go camping near Shelter Island, New York? Hipcamp has over 390 options for you to choose from, with accommodations ranging from tents to cabins. With an average price per night of $53 and options as low as $30, you're sure to find something that fits your budget. Check out top campsites like Mickelberry Forest Gardens (104 reviews), Black Rabbit Farm (109 reviews), and Moon In The Pond Farm (100 reviews). Enjoy popular amenities like showers, pet-friendly areas, and toilets, and explore activities such as hiking, boating, and biking.